Save
This sweet onion sauce perfectly replicates the beloved Subway classic with its balanced profile of punchy onion flavor, delightful sweetness, and subtle tangy notes. Whether slathered on sandwiches or used as a versatile dipping sauce, this homemade version delivers all the signature taste without leaving home.
I first recreated this sauce when my son insisted he would only eat sandwiches with "the special Subway sauce." Now our family actually prefers this homemade version, which we keep stocked in squeeze bottles for quick sandwich assembly.
Ingredients
- 1 cup granulated sugar provides the signature sweetness that balances the vinegar and onion
- White vinegar and red wine vinegar create the perfect tangy foundation
- Freshly grated onion adds real onion flavor impossible to achieve with powders alone
- Dijon mustard brings subtle heat and creaminess to the texture
- Cornstarch serves as the crucial thickening agent for perfect drizzling consistency
- Dried minced onion adds texture and enhances the onion flavor profile
- Sesame oil contributes a nutty undertone that elevates the entire sauce
- Poppy seeds and celery seeds offer tiny bursts of flavor and visual appeal
- Seasonings like paprika and black pepper create depth in every spoonful
Step-by-Step Instructions
- Combine Ingredients
- Whisk all ingredients thoroughly in a small saucepan until completely incorporated. Take extra care to break up any cornstarch lumps as they will cause unpleasant texture issues later. The mixture will appear somewhat separated at first but will come together as it heats.
- Bring to Boil
- Heat the mixture over medium high heat while whisking constantly. This prevents the sugar from burning on the bottom while allowing the cornstarch to activate properly. The mixture will begin to thicken as it approaches boiling point. Look for the first large bubbles to break the surface.
- Simmer to Thicken
- Reduce heat to low immediately once boiling begins and continue to simmer for about 5 minutes. Whisk frequently during this stage to ensure even cooking and prevent any scorching. The sauce should coat the back of a spoon when properly thickened.
- Cool and Store
- Allow the sauce to cool completely at room temperature before transferring to containers. The sauce will continue to thicken slightly as it cools. For best results, refrigerate for at least 4 hours before first use to allow flavors to fully develop.
My favorite ingredient in this sauce is definitely the combination of both fresh and dried onion. I learned through many test batches that using only one form of onion never quite captured that distinctive Subway flavor. The layering of different onion preparations creates that authentic depth my family immediately recognized.
Perfect Pairings
This sweet onion sauce elevates far more than just sandwiches. Try drizzling it over grilled chicken for an instant flavor boost, or use as a unique salad dressing when thinned with a touch of olive oil. The sauce also makes an exceptional glaze for roasted vegetables, particularly carrots and brussels sprouts, where its sweetness enhances the natural vegetable flavors.
Customization Options
For a spicier version, add a pinch of cayenne pepper or a teaspoon of sriracha to the base recipe. Those seeking a more robust garlic presence can double the garlic powder or add a clove of freshly minced garlic during cooking. For a hint of smokiness, substitute the regular paprika with smoked paprika, which pairs beautifully with the onion base.
Troubleshooting Tips
If your sauce becomes too thick after refrigeration, simply warm it slightly and whisk in a teaspoon of water until reaching desired consistency. Should your sauce taste too sweet, balance it with an additional half teaspoon of vinegar. For sauce that seems too thin, return to a saucepan and simmer for 1 2 additional minutes to reduce further.
Recipe FAQs
- → How long does homemade sweet onion sauce last?
When stored in an airtight container in the refrigerator, the homemade sweet onion sauce will last up to 4 weeks. For longer storage, you can freeze it.
- → Can I make this sauce with less sugar?
Yes, for a low-carb, keto, or diabetic-friendly version, you can substitute the granulated sugar with a 1:1 sugar alternative that measures cup for cup with sugar.
- → What's the best way to grate onion for this sauce?
The best way to grate onion for this sauce is using a rasp grater with small holes. Alternatively, you can use a garlic press to get a similar consistency.
- → What can I serve with sweet onion sauce?
Sweet onion sauce pairs perfectly with sandwiches (especially ones with turkey, ham, or roast beef), wraps, as a salad dressing, a dipping sauce for vegetables, or as a marinade for meats.
- → Why does the sauce need cornstarch?
Cornstarch acts as a thickening agent that gives the sauce its proper consistency. Without it, the sauce would be too thin and runny.
- → Can I adjust the spice level of this sauce?
Yes, you can adjust the spice level by increasing or decreasing the amount of black pepper and paprika used in the recipe according to your taste preferences.